Decision-Making Models for Agency Owners When the Future Feels Foggy

Running an agency requires constant decision-making. From hiring to reducing, investing to pausing, shifting offers to scaling up, the decision load never really stops.

When things are going well, these choices feel strategic, exciting, and even empowering. 

But when things are uncertain, it all starts to feel heavy, foggy, and overwhelming.

When this happens, many agency owners freeze, not because they don’t know what to do, but because decision fatigue has set in. It’s one of the most common challenges we see across the firms we work with.

No one knows everything. The good news is that effective decision-making doesn’t require leaders to have all the answers (that’s an impossible feat for anyone). They just need a better model.

Below are three decision-making frameworks we use with agency clients when the path forward feels unclear: financial, resource allocation, and short-term planning. These aren’t meant to be fancy. They’re designed to get teams unstuck.

1. The Financial Decision-Making Model

This model is the foundation of decision-making for agencies. Smart financial decisions start with knowing what’s coming in and what’s going out.

What’s Going Out:

• Know the run rate. What are the absolute, non-negotiable costs to keep the business alive? These are items like core staff, accounting, key software, and necessary subscriptions.
• Understand the margins. How profitable is client work? Is the agency tracking delivery cost versus billed rate?
• Define company costs into tiers.
• Must-haves: The business won’t run without these. Examples include project management systems, key client-facing team members, and financial systems.
• Important: These help things move faster or more smoothly, but wouldn’t halt work without it. Examples include non-essential roles and tools.
• Nice-to-haves: These are good to have when profitable, but expendable if needed. Examples include niche SaaS tools, pricey culture-building initiatives (get scrappy), extra creative tools, and subscriptions that aren’t being fully used.

What’s Coming In:

• Maintain a 90-day look-ahead on revenue. Know which contracts are active, when they end, and whether they’re expected to renew. This gives a clear snapshot of near-term stability.
• Track project end dates and contract expirations. Flag the end dates in the financial dashboard and pipeline. For example, if three retainers are ending next month and not yet renewed, that’s a proactive flag, not something to be surprised by later.
• Align forecasts with the sales pipeline. Pair projected income with realistic pipeline figures. If the agency is forecasting a $40K shortfall in 60 days, what’s actually in the pipeline to close that gap, and how likely is it to land?

Why does this matter?

In times of uncertainty, or even rapid growth, leaders need to make decisions based on data, not drama. This model helps agency leaders stay out of reactive mode and ahead of what’s coming.

2. The Resource Allocation Model

Let’s say the financial model reveals that things are tight, or even just shifting. That’s where resource allocation becomes critical.

This model helps clarify: Where should the firm’s people, time, and attention be focused?

Consider:

• Which roles or team members are delivering the highest return right now? Think beyond just revenue. Who is protecting key relationships? Who is actively driving retention, closing deals, or creating major leverage? If a team member left tomorrow, would it materially affect client success or cash flow?
• Are there marketing efforts that could be paused or simplified? In tight seasons, it's not the time to experiment widely. Rather, it’s time to double down on what is proven to drive leads, sales, or trust. Simplify the scope and free up internal capacity for client delivery or revenue-driving strategy.
• What initiatives or offerings are no longer pulling their weight? Are team members spending hours on something that hasn’t gained traction? Is there a service that sounded good but isn’t selling or producing strong results? It might be time to pause it until the business has more bandwidth.

And importantly, what is the service mix telling us?

• Double down on flagship services. These are the most profitable, high-leverage services that drive retention and are easiest to sell. Prioritize resources toward selling and delivering these.
• Reframe or tighten the scope on bespoke services. Custom work isn’t necessarily a problem, but it requires clear boundaries and strong margins. Revisit pricing and delivery structure before continuing.
• Reevaluate low-profit services. Stop selling what doesn’t scale. If existing clients are on low-margin packages, consider whether to raise prices, phase them out, or shift resources elsewhere.

This is the moment to focus resources on what builds revenue, supports the pipeline, and retains key clients.

Don’t underestimate the power of pausing. Often, agency owners try to keep every initiative alive, but when the path forward feels murky, permission to pause (even temporarily) can be the most strategic move. Focus on the one or two things that matter most right now.

Not everything needs to be cut, but everything should be justified.

3. Strategic Planning (When the Future Feels Unclear)

At the beginning of the year, most firms build strategic plans under ideal conditions with a big vision and optimism. 

When the path gets foggy, those plans can feel irrelevant, or even paralyzing.

This is where a short-term, focused, and incredibly flexible strategic planning model comes into play.

We suggest that our agency partners use a few prompts to ground real-time decision-making:

• What’s true right now?
• What’s urgent (or at risk if nothing changes)?
• What would success look like in the next 90 days?
• What are one or two moves that can support that goal without blowing up team capacity?

For example, let’s say several high-value contracts are up for renewal in the next 90 days. Instead of chasing new ideas or spreading the team thin, a grounded plan might focus on strengthening those relationships by: 

• Delivering clean, on-time work
• Proactively showcasing value and wins
• Increasing communication touchpoints with key decision-makers
• Making it easy for them to renew

Don’t get distracted by every potential direction. Focus on the few levers that are most likely to retain revenue and reinforce trust.

This isn’t about abandoning the long-term vision. It’s about regaining footing in the short term so that the business is in a stable position to propel forward towards long-term goals. 

Even in the most stable times, no business was ever truly predicting the future, although we all felt safer pretending we could.

Final Thought

Agencies don’t need more hustle, more headcount, or better guesses.

They need models that create clarity in the fog.

Financial models give the facts.
Resource allocation shows what’s working.
Short-term planning keeps momentum alive.

If a firm is navigating decision fatigue or stalled growth, a better decision-making model can unlock the next move.

Want support in making your next high-leverage decision with absolute certainty? Book a Clarity Catalyst Call with our founder here.

Or if you’d like to learn more about best practices for PR & marketing agency teams, follow our founder on social media–Instagram, LinkedIn, and YouTube.